$1,399,999
258 Andrew Street, Newmarket, ON L3Y 1H2
4 Beds
4 Baths
4 Parking
As Featured In The Newmarket 2025 Holiday Home Tour, This Exquisite Custom Built Designer Home Is Situated In The Heart Of Newmarket. Constructed In 2017, This Impeccable Home Showcases Superior Craftsmanship With Tens Of Thousands Spent On Upgrades And Premium Finishes Throughout. Spanning Approximately 2,033 Square Feet Above Grade Plus A Fully-Finished Lower Level, This Property Offers Sophisticated Living Spaces Defined By Soaring 9 Foot Ceilings On The Main Lower Floor. The Main Level Is Flooded With Natural Light From An Abundance Of Large Windows, Highlighting The Stunning Engineered Hardwood Flooring That Flows Throughout. The Gourmet Kitchen Is A Chef's Dream, Equipped With Quartz Countertops, An Island With 110V Outlet, Stainless Steel Appliances And Convenient Walk-Out To The Yard. Adjoining The Kitchen Is The Inviting Great Room With A Cozy Gas Fireplace, Perfect For Family Gatherings. The Formal Dining Room Is A Showstopper, Featuring A Magnificent Coffered Ceiling And Elegant Wall Panelling. Ascend To The Second Floor To Find A Convenient Laundry Room With Vaulted Ceilings, Quartz Counters, And Electrolux Appliances. The Primary Retreat Features A Stylish Shiplap Accent Wall, Walk-In Closet, And Luxurious 5-Piece Ensuite,. Two Additional Bedrooms Share A Well-Appointed 5-Piece Jack And Jill Bathroom. The Professionally Finished Basement Expands The Living Space With Durable Vinyl Flooring, Spacious Recreation Room, 3-Piece Bathroom, And Fourth Bedroom Perfect For Guests. Outside, Enjoy $45,000 In Landscaping Creating A Backyard Oasis, Including Patio, Fence, And Hot Tub. This Home Is Perfectly Positioned For An Active Lifestyle In An Amazing Location. Just Steps Away, You Can Explore The Natural Beauty Of Fairy Lake And Its Scenic Walking Trails. The Area Is Also Excitedly Awaiting The Upcoming Mulock Park, Destined To Be A Community Hub. With Historic Main Street Just A Stroll Away, You Have The Best Of Nature And Urban Amenities At Your Doorstep.

Property Summary

Property Type Residential Freehold
Property Sub Type Detached
Transaction Type For Sale
Style 2-Storey
Bedrooms Above Grade 3
Bedrooms Below Grade 1
Bathrooms 4
Kitchens 1
Basement Finished
Exposure South
Possession 60 Days

Building

Building Type Detached
Square Footage 2000-2500
Exterior Stone, Vinyl Siding
Foundation Concrete
Roof Asphalt Shingle
Heating Forced Air
Heat Source Gas
Cooling Central Air
Fireplace Yes

Measurements

Lot Size 50 x 106
Lot Size Units Feet
Frontage 50
Depth 106
Total Living Area 2000-2500

Land

Address 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket, ON L3Y 1H2
City Newmarket
Community Central Newmarket
County / Area York
Cross Street Eagle St & Lorne Ave
Sewer Sewer
Pool None
Parcel Number 035930029

Parking and Garage

Total Parking 4
Garage Spaces 2
Garage Type Attached
Parking Features Private

Taxes and Listing Info

List Price $1,399,999
Annual Taxes $6,847
Tax Year 2025
Status Active
Listing Date 2026-05-12T12:21:40Z
Updated 2026-05-25T12:24:26Z
MLS Number N13114952
Local Market Insight

What Buyers Should Know About 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket, ON L3Y 1H2

This editorial summary helps buyers look beyond the headline price and review the neighbourhood, transit, schools, rental demand, long-term value, and due-diligence items that often matter before booking a showing or submitting an offer.

Neighbourhood Analysis

258 Andrew Street, Newmarket, ON L3Y 1H2 is positioned in Central Newmarket, a part of Newmarket where buyers should compare the street setting, nearby amenities, daily travel routes, and surrounding housing stock. For a 2-Storey, the strongest fit often depends on whether the location supports everyday routine as well as the numbers on paper.

School And Family Considerations

Families reviewing this Detached should confirm school boundaries directly with the local school boards before relying on listing notes. It is also worth checking walkability to parks, childcare, recreation centres, libraries, and community facilities because these details can influence both lifestyle value and future resale demand.

Transit And Access

The location should be assessed around commute patterns, access to Eagle St & Lorne Ave, public transit options, parking availability, and drive times to employment areas. A property with 4 parking and practical road access can appeal to buyers who need convenience without giving up neighbourhood quality.

Investment Potential

At $1,399,999, buyers should compare recent nearby sales, days on market, condition, lot utility, and the cost of future repairs or upgrades. The property shows 4 bedrooms, 4 bathrooms, basement details marked as Finished, and a lot size of 50 x 106, all of which can affect value.

Rental Demand

If this property is being reviewed as a rental or investment, demand should be measured by bedroom count, transit access, employment access, nearby schools, parking, and the condition of the unit or home. In Newmarket, rental appeal usually improves when a property is easy to maintain and simple for tenants to live in.

Local Attractions And Amenities

Buyers should look at grocery access, restaurants, trails, parks, shopping, medical services, and weekend amenities around Central Newmarket. These features do not always appear in the MLS data, but they can make a major difference in how the home feels after move-in and how future buyers compare it.

Builder, Condition, And Due Diligence

For resale homes, review renovations, permits, roof and mechanical age, exterior condition, inclusions, and rental items. For condo or newer properties, review building history, maintenance fees, reserve fund information, rules, amenities, and future cost exposure. A showing and document review should confirm anything not visible in the listing.

Nearby Infrastructure

Infrastructure matters because transit improvements, road projects, schools, parks, commercial growth, and employment nodes can change how an area performs over time. For 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket, ON L3Y 1H2, buyers should check municipal plans, nearby construction, zoning context, and future projects that may affect enjoyment or resale value.

This section is informational only. Buyers should verify schools, measurements, rental rules, taxes, zoning, and property condition with the appropriate professionals before making a decision.

Listing data is provided through PropTx/MLS data services and is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Listings are subject to change without notice.